Is there such thing as "Original Idea"

ASHOOR

Administrator
Staff member
Do you guys beleive there is any such thing as "Original Idea"
I don't think there is. No matter how original the idea looks or sounds, it must have been copied from something else. Sometimes the copying is done intentionally and sometimes it is done on a subcounsious level.

Let us take the "Internet" as an example. Sounds very original la? and it is. But it is only original in its specific form. But on its very basic form, it is not original. It is still a way of communication, much like telephone.

Let us use the phone as our next example. Phone sounds like a very creative and original idea la? yes it is, but if you think about it, the idea of a phone is to let people talk to one another over long distances. The specific idea sounds very original, but the general idea behind it is still not original 100%. The idea of a phone and its purpose can be traced back to the idea of "exchanging letters" which has been going on for thousands of years. The only difference is, with the phone it is quicker and instead of a plain paper, you get the actual voice of the person.

By the way, this is not only about technology. Even in literature. Shakespeare never invented "Tragedy", as it was there from the Greeks; he only reinvented it and added more flavor to it.

In fact, George.T.S.Elliot, the famous English poet once said something like this: "small poets borrow, big poets steal..."


So really, it is hard to find an original idea. Everything has been put for us from the beginning and we are only changing these ideas and making them more sophesticated.



Anyone beg to differ and preferablly with an example?
 
Senalko said:
ashoor said:
Do you guys beleive there is any such thing as "Original Idea"
?


Well i have Written alot of topics in my life, and very recently, some religious ones, But no matter how original i was in my ideads, NO topic can ever be designed or Written without Refences or reading previous ideas to make my reaserch on....

I Guess the word Origin takes you back to the Creator, in the Sense that GOD is the Origin of everything, thus everything and anything we DO in life is not of our own but that of our Creator.....

However, in modern day interpetations, You are still Credited with " Original Work" Status provided u can Prove that the words are your own , the Findings are your own, and the Conclusion are your own.. and provided that You Can provide Credible prefrrences .......

Even original Inventions were based on previous inventions......


SO based on this topic, Was AVN an Original peice of Art? lol or was it created from a previous Forum idea?



Excellent post, and I like the part about God being the origin of everything, which he is.

As to the part about AVN, you had to bring it ha :mad: lol. Well sure the idea is not original, but just like Shakespeare, we made it more fun and popular to chat and communicate with Assyrians :mrgreen:

ASHOOR
 
It's funny you should talk about originality. People who are original are often times accused of being "odd"; and are pushed off to the margins of what's considered the norm/popular. Originality doesn't exist. It's been dead since the advent of the television, internet, etc (ie. mass media leading to the creation of this "global village"). That's what I personally think.
 
i am not like anyone. i am me! the compelling force of all times has been the force of originality.

mr. god lover, if did not grow up in a religious family, would have cared so much about god...originality exists and it seems to be poisoned by our surroundings...only few beings seem to be immune to such poison.
 
Back
Top