Do you ever get mistaken for another ethnicity?

Ezidi Kurd said:
Everything what I wrote about Assyrian is true. Kurds can't trust Assyrians or any other non-Kurdish ethnicity.
I know very much how Assyrian think.

But I share the same enemies wit the Assyrians: the Sunni Muslims! I share their hatred toward the MUSLIMS!


Muslims are enemies of the Assyrians and the Ezdi Kurds.


I LOVE Chaldeans though...


They know very well what I think about the PKK. I'm here on this site longer than 1 year.


Without PKK there would be no Kurds. PKK = REAL Kurdish people. PKK = Kurdistan. Power to PKK, power to the people.

Kurds can't trust Assyrians??? :mfr_lol: :giggle: are you like trying to be ironic and reverse what should be 'Assyrians can (NEVER) trust Kurds'

Come on, you are a Ezidi and should know better: if it wasn't for Kurds betraying you guys in 2014, your women and children wouldn't have been enslaved, raped and killed. And here is the shocker: the Kurds didn't just run away out of fear from ISIS, it was a strategic decision, all to gain some lands at the end, at the expense of the Ezidis (and Assyrians of course)

If I was you, I would be proud of being Ezidi, and that is it, no need to be kissing the @ss of those who betrayed you guys.



ASHOOR
 
Ezidi Kurd said:
Sunni Muslim Daesh terrorist Barzani the Islamist betrayed the Ezdi. He wants to be part of Islam Nation. He has nothing to do with the Kurds and Kurdistan. We will get him and his children.

REAL Kurds should stick together. Together we are strong and undefeatable. Together, the REAL Kurds will defeat all our enemies.

PKK are the REAL Kurds and liberated Shingal from the Muslims. PKK are the majority of Kurds. PKK is a pan-Kurdish and protects not only Barzanistan, but the whole Kurdistan. That's why I'm saying that PKK = Kurdistan, PKK = REAL Kurds.


Many Northern & Eastern non-Ezdi Kurds died for Ezdixan and are buried on our beloved holy mountain.

" I went to ?erfedin Tomb and then Martyr Berxwedan and Martyr Dilge? Cemeteries. When I looked the name of martyries, I realized that most of them are from North Kurdistan. Many people, who came from Amed, Van, Batman and Rojhilat to liberate Shengal, fell martyr. "

http://www.jinha.com.tr/en/ALL-NEWS/content/view/50788

The Ezdi Kurds are the REAL Kurds. We speak a Kurdish language, our religion is native Kurdish, since it is also in Kurdish. And we are the living evidence that the Kurds are native to Kurdistan.

Without the Ezdi Kurds, Kurds don't exist. That's why people try do destory the Ezdi Kurd. But that will never happen. The Ezdi Kurds are becoming stronger. We have liberated our region, We rule our region and the Ezdi Kurds have their army now. Everything will be fine from now on, so don't worry my friend.


Are you like writing a poem or just in fantasy land? There is about 6.5 million Kurds in Iraq, the majority of whom support Barazani, and you are telling they don't exist or are not real Kurds? Well how about this, and as much as we all hate to see that, Kurds in Iraq could declare independence before Kurds in Turkey could ever dream of doing that.

You say Kurds don't trust Assyrians and now you are blasting Kurds in Iraq? I am confused...

Secondly, if you mean Kurds in Turkey don't trust Assyrians, that doesn't make sense whatsoever, because it is not like Assyrians in Turkey have bothered or killed from Kurds. If anything, Assyrians fought alongside PKK in the past.


Get your facts straight and stop being confused. You made some sense in the past (in threads from last year) but not much in this.


ASHOOR
 
mrzurnaci said:
sounds about correct. the first known writing mentioning Kurds go all the way back to the Sassanid Persians with King Ardashir.

Thing is though, he used Kurd in the context of "nomad" rather then a people. The real question is when did "Kurd" stop meaning nomad and started meaning a people?

it's similar to how Assyrian originally meant "Ashurian" from the city of Ashur but the meaning of the name changed when the empire expanded and then fell.


The perception of Kurds as "modern invaders" comes from the fact that a vast amount of the Kurds were migrated from what is now Iran and Azerbaijan into Mesopotamia and Armenia by the Turkish Ottomans.

Hi,

Kurd does not mean Nomad. All the Iranic tribes were nomads, because the proto-Iranic expansion into the M.E. was conducted by nomadic Iranic tribes from Central Asia. This means that, everyone, including the Persians were at some points Nomads. The Iranic tribes added no real value apart from being military superior to the locals, as they were a warrior cast race, where as the locals were already beyond that point in evolution.

Kurd simply means those from the mountains, now, the better question to ask is, when did Kurds evolve into a sole Iranic people when in the past Kurds included Iranics and Semite people - although, the Jewish (Semite) Kurds still exist.

Iranic Kurds are split, as I said before, into Median and Parthian components. The Kurmanji (Kur-Magi) or son of the Magis and Hawrami/Guranis (the Parthians). Remember that the Persians were a vasal state of the Medes, and it was only after a royal unification and the betrayel from the Persian side that the Medes collapsed as an entity. After that, the nationalist Mede tribes, in particular the Magis, continued to look for a different identity to the now dominant Persians, so over time, they became Kurds.

Additionally, before the Mongols arrived in the area, Kurds were slowely taking over Iran. In fact, Historians say that if it wasn't for the Mongols, maybe Kurds will be leading Iran today.

As for being recent invaders, that simply isn't true! how can you say that Kurds moved to Mesopotamia during the Ottoman times when leading Kurdish figures and dyansties were present before them?

Thanks,
Alan 
 
alan1 said:
Hi,

Kurd does not mean Nomad. All the Iranic tribes were nomads, because the proto-Iranic expansion into the M.E. was conducted by nomadic Iranic tribes from Central Asia. This means that, everyone, including the Persians were at some points Nomads. The Iranic tribes added no real value apart from being military superior to the locals, as they were a warrior cast race, where as the locals were already beyond that point in evolution.

Kurd simply means those from the mountains, now, the better question to ask is, when did Kurds evolve into a sole Iranic people when in the past Kurds included Iranics and Semite people - although, the Jewish (Semite) Kurds still exist.

Iranic Kurds are split, as I said before, into Median and Parthian components. The Kurmanji (Kur-Magi) or son of the Magis and Hawrami/Guranis (the Parthians). Remember that the Persians were a vasal state of the Medes, and it was only after a royal unification and the betrayel from the Persian side that the Medes collapsed as an entity. After that, the nationalist Mede tribes, in particular the Magis, continued to look for a different identity to the now dominant Persians, so over time, they became Kurds.

Additionally, before the Mongols arrived in the area, Kurds were slowely taking over Iran. In fact, Historians say that if it wasn't for the Mongols, maybe Kurds will be leading Iran today.

As for being recent invaders, that simply isn't true! how can you say that Kurds moved to Mesopotamia during the Ottoman times when leading Kurdish figures and dyansties were present before them?

Thanks,
Alan 

I never said Kurd meant nomad, I said the letter was using it in the sense of "nomad" rather than a distinct people. Here's the full writing.

"In a letter Ardashir I received from his foe, Ardavan V"

"You've bitten off more than you can chew
and you have brought death to yourself.
O son of a Kurd, raised in the tents of the Kurds,
who gave you permission to put a crown on your head?"


According to James Boris (don't get mad at me, contact Mr. Boris about this info), the word 'Kurd' first became an ethnic identity in the 12th and 13th century aka the 1100s and the 1200s.

James Boris might be wrong because there's writings by Assyrian bishops writing about Kurds in the 900s and 1000s.

Here's a source for that info -> James, Boris. (2006). Uses and Values of the Term Kurd in Arabic Medieval Literary Sources. Seminar at the American University of Beirut, pp. 6-7.


"Kurd simply means those from the mountains, now, the better question to ask is, when did Kurds evolve into a sole Iranic people when in the past Kurds included Iranics and Semite people - although, the Jewish (Semite) Kurds still exist. "

So Kurds are a mix of Iranians and Assyrians? The only Semites that would've been near the Zagros would've been Assyrians or Arabs that migrated to Assyria.

"Additionally, before the Mongols arrived in the area, Kurds were slowely taking over Iran. In fact, Historians say that if it wasn't for the Mongols, maybe Kurds will be leading Iran today. "

I read that the Mongols barely affected Kurds because of their nomadic status, if there was trouble, they could just do hit and runs and run away as they didn't have a permanent settlement like Assyrians and Iranians did. You can ignore this since I forgot the source that said this info.


"the nationalist Mede tribes, in particular the Magis, continued to look for a different identity to the now dominant Persians, so over time, they became Kurds. "

Nationalism didn't exist until the late 1800s so this really sounds like conjecture, I require a source plz!


"As for being recent invaders, that simply isn't true! how can you say that Kurds moved to Mesopotamia during the Ottoman times when leading Kurdish figures and dyansties were present before them? "

I never said Kurds were recent invaders... Let me give a better context.

The Battle of Chaldiran occurred between the Sunni Muslim Ottomans and the Shi'a Safavid Persians. Ottomans recruited the Sunni Kurds because the Shi'a Persians oppressed and persecuted them for being Sunni.

Kurds joined in this battle with the Ottoman achieving victory. The Ottomans reward Kurds by migrating them into northern Mesopotamia from Northwest Iran and Azerbaijan...

Yes, Azerbaijan originally was Kurdish but the migration of Kurds by the Ottomans allowed Azeri Turks to move there...
 
mrzurnaci said:
I never said Kurd meant nomad, I said the letter was using it in the sense of "nomad" rather than a distinct people. Here's the full writing.

"In a letter Ardashir I received from his foe, Ardavan V"

"You've bitten off more than you can chew
and you have brought death to yourself.
O son of a Kurd, raised in the tents of the Kurds,
who gave you permission to put a crown on your head?"

This is a simple error in translation. Ardashir was a Kurd himself, hence the text you posted "in a letter Ardashir I received from his foe" in which he calls Ardashir a son of  kurd, rasied in the tents of the Kurds. This isn't to say that Kurds were nomads, but that he was from Nomadic Tribe, because at the time, Kurds had Nomad and non-Nomad tribes. I wouldn't be surpised if this was meant to be insult (i.e. refer to a low-class Kurdish tribe) even though Aradashir was not from a Nomad Kurdish tribe.

By contrast, Saladins ancestors were Ezidis from Modern day Armenia. They convereted to Islam when they arrived in Tirkir. Saladins initial army were majority Kurdish, and his generals and right hand men were Kurds.

Also, Saladin paid Kurds in his army, twice the rate he paid Arabs from Egypt for example, because he stated that they Arabs did not make good soldiers.

According to James Boris (don't get mad at me, contact Mr. Boris about this info), the word 'Kurd' first became an ethnic identity in the 12th and 13th century aka the 1100s and the 1200s.

James Boris might be wrong because there's writings by Assyrian bishops writing about Kurds in the 900s and 1000s.

Here's a source for that info -> James, Boris. (2006). Uses and Values of the Term Kurd in Arabic Medieval Literary Sources. Seminar at the American University of Beirut, pp. 6-7.

Different Historians have different views. Now a days many Historians have a different view. This can NOT be true, and I already told you, because a Kurdish Muslim scholar already spoke about the ancestory of the Kurds, and wrote about about it prior to this date.

So Kurds are a mix of Iranians and Assyrians? The only Semites that would've been near the Zagros would've been Assyrians or Arabs that migrated to Assyria.

I will not put an ethinic name to it, because even prior to the Assyrians people existed in the region. Kurds are simply the outcome of thousands of years of integration.

I read that the Mongols barely affected Kurds because of their nomadic status, if there was trouble, they could just do hit and runs and run away as they didn't have a permanent settlement like Assyrians and Iranians did. You can ignore this since I forgot the source that said this info.

I will post the links to that later. Kurds already took over much of North-Western Iran before the Mongols arrived.

Nationalism didn't exist until the late 1800s so this really sounds like conjecture, I require a source plz!

You're thinking of Nationalism in modern nation state regard, but "nationalism" (which refers to ones defence of identity) existed prior to that, especially in the M.E. Off course it didn't exist in Europe because back they Europeans were dancing around fires and painted blue.

I never said Kurds were recent invaders... Let me give a better context.
The Battle of Chaldiran occurred between the Sunni Muslim Ottomans and the Shi'a Safavid Persians. Ottomans recruited the Sunni Kurds because the Shi'a Persians oppressed and persecuted them for being Sunni.

Kurds joined in this battle with the Ottoman achieving victory. The Ottomans reward Kurds by migrating them into northern Mesopotamia from Northwest Iran and Azerbaijan...

Yes, Azerbaijan originally was Kurdish but the migration of Kurds by the Ottomans allowed Azeri Turks to move there...

The Kurds and Ottoman Turks had an agreement in which Kurds were laregly autonomous, in fact, many European countries were conquered by Kurdish armies and not Turkish ones. For example, you will find many Hungarians with the second name "Kurdi"

Azerbaijan would have been part of Kurdistan had it not been Turkified, that is true. They were also Median tribes, but there was no such exchange! the Azeris were turkified with the rest of Central Asia.
 
alan1 said:
This is a simple error in translation. Ardashir was a Kurd himself, hence the text you posted "in a letter Ardashir I received from his foe" in which he calls Ardashir a son of  kurd, rasied in the tents of the Kurds. This isn't to say that Kurds were nomads, but that he was from Nomadic Tribe, because at the time, Kurds had Nomad and non-Nomad tribes. I wouldn't be surpised if this was meant to be insult (i.e. refer to a low-class Kurdish tribe) even though Aradashir was not from a Nomad Kurdish tribe.

By contrast, Saladins ancestors were Ezidis from Modern day Armenia. They convereted to Islam when they arrived in Tirkir. Saladins initial army were majority Kurdish, and his generals and right hand men were Kurds.

Also, Saladin paid Kurds in his army, twice the rate he paid Arabs from Egypt for example, because he stated that they Arabs did not make good soldiers.

Different Historians have different views. Now a days many Historians have a different view. This can NOT be true, and I already told you, because a Kurdish Muslim scholar already spoke about the ancestory of the Kurds, and wrote about about it prior to this date.

I will not put an ethinic name to it, because even prior to the Assyrians people existed in the region. Kurds are simply the outcome of thousands of years of integration.

I will post the links to that later. Kurds already took over much of North-Western Iran before the Mongols arrived.

You're thinking of Nationalism in modern nation state regard, but "nationalism" (which refers to ones defence of identity) existed prior to that, especially in the M.E. Off course it didn't exist in Europe because back they Europeans were dancing around fires and painted blue.

I never said Kurds were recent invaders... Let me give a better context.
The Kurds and Ottoman Turks had an agreement in which Kurds were laregly autonomous, in fact, many European countries were conquered by Kurdish armies and not Turkish ones. For example, you will find many Hungarians with the second name "Kurdi"

Azerbaijan would have been part of Kurdistan had it not been Turkified, that is true. They were also Median tribes, but there was no such exchange! the Azeris were turkified with the rest of Central Asia.

Considering almost all of what you said conflicts with my history books and my contacts with the historians and professors of the University of Chicago. I'm afraid I have no choice but you blacklist you as another biased Middle Eastern writer.

You and those guys are the exact reason why I never read or listen to history according to Middle Eastern writers or historians.

The lecture is either biased, lies, conjecture, projection, or a mixture of all four.

I'm sticking to Western historians and archaeologists...
 
mrzurnaci said:
Considering almost all of what you said conflicts with my history books and my contacts with the historians and professors of the University of Chicago. I'm afraid I have no choice but you blacklist you as another biased Middle Eastern writer.

You and those guys are the exact reason why I never read or listen to history according to Middle Eastern writers or historians.

The lecture is either biased, lies, conjecture, projection, or a mixture of all four.

I'm sticking to Western historians and archaeologists...

You're free to believe in what ever you wish. I am not qouting M.E. historians.

Additionally, I am not a Historian, I am an Engineer, and while I find history interesting, I don't particularly care for it much because at the end of the day

"History is not written by he who was right, but he who won"

Just remember, that today we are writing History, and, many lies and proganada of today will be considered fact in a few centutries.
 
alan1 said:
You're free to believe in what ever you wish. I am not qouting M.E. historians.

Additionally, I am not a Historian, I am an Engineer, and while I find history interesting, I don't particularly care for it much because at the end of the day

"History is not written by he who was right, but he who won"

Just remember, that today we are writing History, and, many lies and proganada of today will be considered fact in a few centutries.
How do we know what is true and what isn't?
 
Anid said:
How do we know what is true and what isn't?

We will never be able to know the full truth, but the extend to which you know the truth depends on your ability to critically analyse things.
 
Can somebody please delete all the above posts that hijacked this thread?

@Atourina, I still see these posts. What did you delete?

__________________________________________________________________

Does anyone find it flattering when they're mistaken for another ethnicity?
 
Neon said:
Can somebody please delete all the above posts that hijacked this thread?

@Atourina, I still see these posts. What did you delete?

__________________________________________________________________

Does anyone find it flattered when they're mistaken for another ethnicity?

The other day some kid called me Italian - felt pretty good, not gonna lie.

Plus, Assyrian isn't usually guessed for someone's ethnicity and I'd rather be mistaken for European than Arab, which is usually the case anyway.
 
Mr. Tambourine Man said:
The other day some kid called me Italian - felt pretty good, not gonna lie.

Plus, Assyrian isn't usually guessed for someone's ethnicity and I'd rather be mistaken for European than Arab, which is usually the case anyway.
Yeah, Italian is really flattering. I like it too. :)

It depends on the Arab ethnicity. I get Lebanese oftentimes and I like that - Lebanese men are really handsome. So I take that as a compliment.

P.S. Other Assyrians usually can tell that I'm Assyrian. But foreigners, especially Europeans or Asians, barely tell that I'm even Middle Eastern.
 
I don't hate looking 'Assyrian', don't get me wrong but problem is, I can't grow those nice majestic beards and stuff.

Maybe it'll reflect with me as I age.
 
Mr. Tambourine Man said:
I don't hate looking 'Assyrian', don't get me wrong but problem is, I can't grow those nice majestic beards and stuff.

Maybe it'll reflect with me as I age.
Yeah, same here. It's just genes, even though my dad and uncles can grow good beards. So I don't know. Could be a recessive trait. Lol.
 
I've been asked if I was Italian, Romanian, Spanish, or Greek.  I always say I'm 100 % Assyrian!  Alqosh/Zerineh/Mardin mix :) ..
 
Dalale said:
I've been asked if I was Italian, Romanian, Spanish, or Greek.  I always say I'm 100 % Assyrian!  Alqosh/Zerineh/Mardin mix :) ..
Didn't know that Zerineh and Mardin were millets. Lol
 
Back
Top