DNA Project ADMIXTURE Results

dok101

New member
Hi guys.  A public project focused on the DNA of South and Central Asian populations, using genome files submitted by 23andMe customer volunteer participants, includes, in addition to three Assyrian samples, a number of other participants relevant to us.  I call your attention, in particular, to the apparent relationship shared between the three Assyrian participants and the S Iraqi Mandaean.  The eleven "C" components are meant to represent different ancestral contributions to an individual's genome.  The program uses the autosomal allele data from a few hundred thousand specific points in one's genome (called SNPs) to calculate the ancestral component percentages.  I created a dendrogram to better frame the relationships between the different individuals, based on the 11 "C" component percentages.  The samples are sorted in descending order based on the most abundant component, "C4."

Code:
Ethnicity	C1	C2	C3	C4	C5	C6	C7	C8	C9	C10	C11
Iraqi Arab1	19%	0%	0%	64%	4%	1%	3%	2%	1%	1%	6%
Irq/Egy Jew	21%	0%	1%	61%	15%	0%	0%	1%	0%	0%	2%
Assyrian1	25%	0%	0%	59%	15%	0%	0%	0%	0%	0%	0%
Assyrian2	25%	0%	0%	58%	16%	1%	0%	0%	0%	0%	0%
Assyrian3	26%	0%	0%	58%	16%	0%	0%	0%	1%	0%	0%
Mandaean	23%	1%	0%	58%	16%	0%	0%	0%	1%	0%	2%
Iraqi Arab2	25%	2%	2%	51%	17%	0%	2%	0%	0%	0%	0%
Iraqi Kurd	30%	1%	1%	48%	18%	2%	0%	0%	0%	0%	0%
Iranian1	29%	1%	2%	46%	19%	2%	0%	0%	1%	0%	0%
Iranian2	33%	0%	0%	46%	17%	3%	0%	0%	0%	1%	0%
Iranian3	29%	0%	2%	46%	19%	2%	0%	0%	0%	0%	1%
Azeri Turk	24%	1%	2%	44%	23%	4%	0%	0%	1%	0%	0%
Iranian4	29%	0%	2%	43%	20%	3%	0%	0%	0%	0%	2%
Iranian5	30%	1%	3%	42%	20%	1%	0%	0%	2%	1%	0%
Georgian	17%	0%	0%	42%	40%	1%	0%	0%	0%	0%	0%
Khorasani	34%	3%	0%	40%	17%	4%	0%	0%	0%	0%	1%

Iraqi Arab1 = S Iraq
Mandaean = S Iraq
Iraqi Arab2 = Baghdad
Iraqi Kurd = N Iraq
Assyrian1 = Iran/Turkey
Assyrian2 = Turkey/Iraq
Assyrian3 = Turkey/Iraq
Iraqi/Egyptian Jewish = Israel

www.harappadna.org/

[youtube]5ZQ7SlpcID0[/youtube]

 

Attachments

  • dendrogram_511.jpg
    dendrogram_511.jpg
    58.8 KB · Views: 655
Again thanks for the topic, very interesting too.

As for the charter, I think its not so represantative yet or, since you need way more people to do tests?
 
Rumtaya said:
Again thanks for the topic, very interesting too.

As for the charter, I think its not so represantative yet or, since you need way more people to do tests?

Yes, we certainly need more Assyrians to test.  

What is not representative?  

If you are referring to us matching the Mandaean first, have you ever read the first few lines of the history of their people, as contained in their book the Haran Gawaitha?  And yes, for all the folks who understand our language, it means the inside of Harran.  Gawaithet Harran.  

For the record, I am absolutely not one to assign the Assyrian label to all people, as some do.  The fact remains, however, that based on what I have seen, Mandaeans and Assyrians, if one ventured far enough back in time, were a closely related people.  In fact, Mandaeism, I think it possible, may have served as a transition faith for a few, most, or all of us, from our former Assyro-Babylonian religion to Christianity.  

Mandaean history, as told by the Mandaeans:
Haran Gawaita
The interior of Harran admitted them, that city which has Nasurai* in it, so that there should not be a road (passage?) for the kings of the Yahutaiia (Chaldeans). Over them (the Nasurai*) was Malka Ardban. And they served themselves from the sign of the Seven and entered the mountain of the Madai (the Median Mountains), a place where they were free from domination of all races. And they built mandis (mandia) and dwelt in the call of the Life and in the strength of the high King of Light.

After the fall of Nineveh, the last Assyrian king, Assur-uballit II, the nobility, and what remained of the Assyrian forces fled to the final Assyrian stronghold, Harran. The Chaldean King Nabopolassar of Babylonia (Yahutaiia), and his Median allies (Madai), led by King Cyaxares (Grandfather of future Queen Mandana of Madai, mother of Cyrus the Great, King of Anshan), followed and laid siege to Harran. In 609 BCE Necho II of Egypt, after defeating a Judaean force attempting to obstruct his army's path, came to the aid of the Assyrians. At Carchemish (on the Euphrates) in 605 BCE the Assyrian-Egyptian forces were finally defeated by the Babylonian (now led by King Nebuchadnezzar II) and Median alliance. The Egyptians retreated, and it is said Assur-uballit II and the Assyrian remnants disappeared from the annals of history.

After Assyria's defeat its lands were divided. Many areas came under Babylonian domination. Other parts became part of the land of the Madai.  Including, of course, the place many of our ancestors fled to, when Timur's hordes laid waste to our villages, Hakkari.  

*
Akkadian: naṣāru
[Army → Military]
to guard, protect , to defend , to safeguard ; to watch , to beware of , to cherish , to preserve / conserve + , to prize , to treasure.

Another note - the Mandaeans, in their texts, refer to both the Jews and Babylonians as "Yahutaiia."  

Encyclopedia Iranica:
Nevertheless, Mandaic inherited abundantly phonetic, grammatical, and lexicographic features from Akkadian (Late Babylonian) that point to the fact that the Mandaeans? origin cannot have been anywhere else than in Mesopotamia (Kaufman, 1974, pp. 163-64; M?ller-Kessler, 2004).

In the area of loanwords, Mandaic inherited from Akkadian an abundance of termini technici concerning religion, but also many words in other areas. Despite the limitation in its attested lexicon, due to the loss of texts, Mandaic shows more Akkadian borrowings than any other Aramaic dialect. The Mandaean gnostic sect recruited from a Babylonian population, and a stock of Akkadian words had belonged to the idiom of that geographical area for some centuries. Particular borrowings in Mandaic are: priest classes, cult, divination, and magic terms: brʾyʾ < bartū ?diviner,? zʾbʾ 2 ?esoteric priests,? gynyʾ ?sacrifice,? ʿkwrʾ < ekurru ?temple,? prykʾ < parakku ?altar, shrine,? py?rʾ < pi?ru ?dissolving of a magic bond,? ʾ?p < a?āpu ?to bewitch,? ?ʾptʾ < ?iptu ?incantation?; terms concerning the gnostic doctrine and cult: gynyʾ < gin? ?sanctuaries,? zywʾ < zīmu ?brilliance,? nʾndbyʾ < nindab? ?offering,? nʾṣwrʾyʾ ?watcher of secrets,? nʾṣyrwtʾ ?secrecy? < niṣirtu; architectional terms: ʾngrʾ < agāru ?wall,?roof,? k?wrʾ < gu?ūru ?beam, post?; body parts: gysʾ 2 ?side?; ktʾ < qātu ?hand, handle,? ?ʾyryʾnʾ < ?vein, artery?; directions of the wind, name of winds, astronomical terms: ?ʾrʾ <?ārū ?direction of the wind,? stʾnʾ < i?tānu north(wind), ywniʾ 2 <ūmu 3 ?storm,? tʾlyʾ < attala ?eclipse.?

Names and other events are frequently, in Mandaean texts, not what they appear.  Possibly, for example, the King (Malka) Ardban.  Scholars have suggested the completely out of chronology Parthian era Ardbans.  None of whom appear a good fit.  Malka Ard-ban, may, perhaps, mean something along the lines of King "Creator of the Earth or City."

Akkadian: ban, N builder / maker.

ban? (4) : (deity) : to create (a person, grain , creation ...) 5) D : : to erect (a city)

Semitic languages words for "earth" - Arabic=ard; Akkadian=irt-situ

There are many, many more possible connections, here are but a few:

Encyclopedia Iranica:
It is assumed that the Mandaean Panja [ceremony] replaced the Babylonian-Assyrian spring festival, the Akitu, under Persian influence and thus lost its old seasonal connection.

Mandaeans of Iraq and Iran, E.S. Drower, Leiden, 1962
I had long been concerned with this question of origins. When I questioned the priests and got the answer 'We came from the North', I did not attach much literal value to the answer, for dwellers in the Middle East cannot distinguish between religion and race, and the divine ancestors naturally resided in the north, the seat of the gods.

But there seemed something more than this in their refusal to acknowledge Lower Iraq as the original home of the race. There is an arrogance, almost worthy of the present 'Nordic' propaganda, about the following, culled from the seventh fragment of the eleventh book of the Ginza Raba ("Great Treasure"):

All the word calls the north a highland and the south a lowland. For the worlds of darkness lie in the lowlands of the South....Whose dwelleth in the North is light of colour but those who live in the lowlands are black and their appearance is ugly like demons.

On the Existence of National Identity Before ?Imagined Communities?: The Example of the Assyrians of Mesopotamia, Anatolia, and Persia (2011)
Hannibal Travis
Florida International University College of Law

The anthropologist Lady Ethel Drower described a ?race and religion? of Mandai or Mandaeans consisting of about 5,000 persons who worshipped God as prophesied by John the Baptist in public, and preserved in their secret scriptures the memory of the Assyro-Babylonian religion they traced to Assyrian Harran.136 Drower judged it impossible to doubt that the Mandaeans were ?an aboriginal cult? of Assyria and Babylon, ?maintaining a continuous and unbroken ritual tradition? going back to the worship of ?ame?, Ea, and Marduk with ritual ablutions on the banks of the Tigris and the Euphrates.137 Building on Drower?s work, a scholar of Semitic languages in 1910 traced Mandaean light-god Mana Rabba to the Assyro-Babylonian Ea, his emanation Manda de hayye and his son Hibil Ziwa with Ea?s son Marduk, stating: ?Ea, the god of profound knowledge, father of the mediator Marduk, enthroned in the world-sea, whose holy element is water, is the Ea of the brilliant ocean of heaven, as comes out in the Ayar-yora and the heavenly Jordan of the Mandaeans.?138
 
A leading Mandaean scholar wrote:

The Mandaeans use a solar calendar which consists of 12 months, each consisting of exactly 30 days, with an additional 5 days added at the end of the year which do not belong to any month. Apparently, this same calendar was used in ancient Egypt throughout most of its history. An additional day once every 4 years was added to the calendar before the first century C.E.

Does this evidence show a connection between the Mandaeans and Egypt which goes back earlier than the first century B.C.E.? Could the Mandaeans have adopted the calendar without ever having lived in Egypt, just through reading or hearing about it? The latter seems unlikely. Other minor details of Mandaean belief (e.g. the name Ptahil, which resembles that of the Egyptian deity Ptah) might also make a connection with Egypt plausible. This need not mean actually living in Egypt proper, since Egypt's territorial holdings reached much further. Would living in the vicinity of the Jordan during the Ptolemaic era have been enough to account for this similarity? Could the Mandaeans simply have come up with the same solution to the problem of the calendar independently of the Egyptians?

The question I'm most interested in is whether the Mandaean calendar allows us to figure out anything at all about the origin and history of the Mandaeans.

The same scholar also added:

It would also be interesting to do DNA testing on the Mandaeans to see whether that can shed light on their relation to other peoples in the Middle East.

Auspicious latitudes
The earliest known tablets that use the 360- degree notation date only from the last few centuries BCE. However, in view of the haphazard survival of such documents and the very fragmentary state of our knowledge basis, this does not necessarily mean the notation began only at that late date. Much circumstantial evidence indicates it must have been much older.

At least a thousand years before those first documented 360- degree notations, the Assyrians had the habit of dividing the yearly cycle into 360 equal parts or "time degrees", as the Assyriologist Simo Parpola explains:

"A schematic year of 360 days divided into twelve months of 30 days each is encountered not only in the Assyrian cultic calendar Inbu bel arhi but also in the late second- millennium astronomical text Mul Apin; in the latter, it is correlated with a division of the solar year into four seasons of equal length, corresponding to the later division of the ecliptic into twelve zodiacal signs of 30 degrees each.

The Fascinating Balanced Sacred Assyrian Tree of Life
The 360 has been a sacred number in Assyria, and the Assyrians based their calendar on 12 x 30 days = 360 days. Fact or fiction, ever since Assyrians stopped using their ancient 360 day calendar, they have not lived life of a happy sovereign nation.
 
Another dendrogram, this time based on the ADMIXTURE results from the Dodecad Ancestry Project.  Many more samples, including many Assyrians, and other folks from our part of the world.  Again, note where the Mandaean falls.  The Mandaeans do NOT accept converts, and they do not proselytize.  Marriages outside of the Mandaean faith are not permitted.  Some say their gnostic faith came before Christianity.  Some believe it dates to the 2nd or 3rd centuries of the common era.

 

Attachments

  • wojciech_dod_4111c.jpg
    wojciech_dod_4111c.jpg
    28.4 KB · Views: 648
Thanks for the sum up of some source on mandaeans ( i have read about them before abit too).


What I meant was just a general statement. How much Assyrians do we need to have a represantive result on how close we are to eachother? 0,01% of our population?

I saw that the tree assyrians match very close to eachother all there would have close diagrams (colors). How many Assyrians have been doing an DNA that far who participated in that studies of yours?

I will do one too, when I am in better financial conditions :D. Can you send the exact link of which dna sample I would need?
t
 
Rumtaya said:
Thanks for the sum up of some source on mandaeans ( i have read about them before abit too).


What I meant was just a general statement. How much Assyrians do we need to have a represantive result on how close we are to eachother? 0,01% of our population?

I saw that the tree assyrians match very close to eachother all there would have close diagrams (colors). How many Assyrians have been doing an DNA that far who participated in that studies of yours?

I will do one too, when I am in better financial conditions :D. Can you send the exact link of which dna sample I would need?
t

That is great, brother.  Here is the link: https://www.23andme.com/store/cart/

In the Dodecad project, I believe, at last count, there were 11 Assyrians.  I put out messages to most all others on 23andMe, but did not hear back.  It is unfortunate, because it is really important for our nation to get our name out there.  Most in the genetic genealogy community had not the slightest clue what or who we were over a year ago.  I can guarantee you, unless they have been living underneath a rock these past few months, that has all changed.  It is difficult to argue against genetic data.  We can tell people we are Assyrians until we are blue in the face.  Words are words.  Science is science.  Without the participation of Assyrian 23andMe testees in public projects (ie Dodecad), we would still be an absolute unknown, as far as our autosomal DNA was concerned.  No academic has yet sampled us for an autosomal study.  It is up to us.  Andre Anton is promoting our cause through film.  God rest their souls, Dr. Donny George and Lina Yakubova were bright shining lights in our community in both of their respective fields.  Rosie Malek Yonan is carrying the political activist torch.  DNA testing is another piece.  And, in my opinion, one of the most important.  DNA testing is something we can all do to contribute.
 
Paul,  is the Dodecad the one I gave you my dad's sample for or was that something else?  Also, since the last 23andme upgrade I have downloadable results as well, even though I had only paid for the cheaper test back in the day.  Let me know if you need my results for any further studies and I'll be happy to join.

I haven't been so active on the DNA research or forums lately.  I've been busy working on my family tree.  I found some papers yesterday that list back to my 5th great grandfather on my Assyrian side. Now I need to talk to family to fill in spouses and children as far back as possible.
 
Jacob.  Just sent you an email with some info.  Thank you so much for helping out!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Failed to add two potentially significant bits, below:

dok101 said:
Mandaean history, as told by the Mandaeans:
Haran Gawaita
The interior of Harran admitted them, that city which has Nasurai* in it, so that there should not be a road (passage?) for the kings of the Yahutaiia (Chaldeans). Over them (the Nasurai*) was Malka Ardban. And they served themselves from the sign of the Seven and entered the mountain of the Madai (the Median Mountains), a place where they were free from domination of all races. And they built mandis (mandia) and dwelt in the call of the Life and in the strength of the high King of Light. 

Encyclopedia Iranica:
Names and other events are frequently, in Mandaean texts, not what they appear.  Possibly, for example, the King (Malka) Ardban.  Scholars have suggested the completely out of chronology Parthian era Ardbans.  None of whom appear a good fit.  Malka Ard-ban, may, perhaps, mean something along the lines of King "Creator of the Earth or City."

Akkadian: ban, N builder / maker.
ban? (4) : (deity) : to create (a person, grain , creation ...) 5) D : : to erect (a city)
Words for "earth" - Arabic=ard; Akkadian=irt-situ

When Assyria conquered Babylon in the Sargonid period (8th-7th centuries BCE), Assyrian scribes began to write the name of Ashur with the cuneiform signs AN.SHAR, literally "whole heaven" in Akkadian, the language of Babylon. The intention seems to have been to put Ashur at the head of the Babylonian pantheon, where Anshar and his counterpart Kishar ("whole earth") preceded even Enlil and Ninlil. Thus in the Sargonid version of the Enuma Elish, the Babylonian national creation myth, Marduk, the chief god of Babylon, does not appear, and instead it is Ashur, as Anshar, who slays Tiamat the chaos-monster and creates the world of humankind.

Or, did King Ardban actually exist.  Between Nineveh and Haran was Arban. 

The British Museum's description of the "Carnelian cylinder seal of Mushezib-Ninurta," makes reference to the ruler of Shadikanni (Arban):
Neo-Assyrian, 9th century BC
From Sherif Khan (Tarbisu), northern Iraq

The owner of this seal can be identified from the cuneiform inscription which translates: 'Seal of Mushezib-Ninurta, governor, son of Ninurta-eresh, ditto, son of Samanuha-shar-ilani, ditto.' Samanuha-shar-ilani was ruler of Shadikanni (Arban in eastern Syria), in 883 BC, and an Assyrian vassal - subject to the firm control of Assyria, and enjoying the wealth and security that such political domination provided.

The image is similar to two wall reliefs from the throne room of King Ashurnasirpal II (reigned 883-859 BC) at Nimrud. The king, shown in mirror image, is protected by guardian genii sprinkling holy water from a bucket using what may be a fir cone or sponge. A stylized tree stands in the centre, symbolizing nature and the land of Assyria. Above is a god in the winged disc probably representing the sun-god Shamash or the supreme god of Assyria, Ashur.
 

Attachments

  • Arban.jpg
    Arban.jpg
    111.3 KB · Views: 540
  • britmus.jpg
    britmus.jpg
    59.5 KB · Views: 505
Back
Top