Discuss: Assyrians listened and repented, but Nineveh still fell?

ASHOOR

Administrator
Staff member
As we fast these days for the Rogation of Nineveh, this question comes to mind...

So God sent Jonah to Nineveh to ask the Assyriams to repent which they did. Yet few decades later, Assyria was still destroyed and couldn't be saved and the great empire fell. What happened? Did God break his promise? Or did his promise only apply to when Jonah was sent?

And speaking of which, God sent so many prophets to the Jews and they still didn't believe or right their ways. With Assyrians, it took just one prophet. Can you say we are the greatest believers in history?


Ashoor
 
If you want a more objective answer; empires rise and fall without the help of gods. There was no promise from deities. For starters, there is no historical evidence of Jonah (and many of the Old Testament prophets). Now parts of the Old Testament were set in historical events, but those that involved the prophets and the supernatural were fictional narratives set in those events (think, Jack & Rose in Titanic).

Say, it's very ironic that there are nationalistic Assyrians (not you) who would brag about the Assyrian empire, display its art, etc, whilst revering the Old Testament, considering how much it antagonized us. :blink:
 
Nineveh fell because our ancient ancestors over-extended without making sure they can recover and maintain the existing territories they conquered, much like the Romans did but it's likely the Romans learned from us not to over-extend quickly without having an adequate force.
 
Back
Top