Coincidence or Coordination? A Critical Look at Recent Anti-Assyrian Rhetoric

ASHOOR

Administrator
Staff member
It has been a brutal last few days in what seems to be coordinated campaign by Chaldean clergy members - and others - on Assyrian church, history and culture. I am sure most of you are familiar with what happened, but let me go through a timeline of these attacks:

  • It all started with the Chaldean Patriarch Louis Raphael Sako a week ago, just before the start of the "Rogation of the Ninevites" (Baoutha D'Ninwaye) , in which he made several shocking claims, including that the whole store of Jonah in the old testament is made up, that he (the prophet) was confused etc. You can see the whole video for yourself. This is in attempt to rename the whole thing and remove the reference to 'Nineveh' and keep it as 'Baoutha' only. Not shocking of course, given his holiness staunch anti-Assyrian stand, which is not secret to anyone.
    Link to the sermon: https://www.facebook.com/reel/4238441113064843

  • But unfortunately, wish that was it. As they say, a few days later, a Chaldean archbishop from Kerkuk (Archbishop Yousif Thomas) said "hold my beer"! He not only doubled down, he went much further by stating that the Assyrians were brutal, that the Assyrian Empire was the ugliest empire known to history, and even as far as considering the story of the Prophet Jonah a fictional tale with no connection to the city of Nineveh (just like his boss stated a few days earlier)
    Link to the sermon: https://www.facebook.com/share/v/17yYtU33sU/

  • In-between these two, there was a third and somewhat unrelated attack. Let me give you the background on that. Assyrian Facebook show "Noqza" interviewed a prominent singer and activist from Alqosh named "Danny Asmaro" about his efforts to rebuild old Alqosh and make it into a prominent cultural and even tourist site for people to come and see. Although the interview was general and neutral and focused mostly on Alqosh as a town, and unrelated to Assyrian or Chaldean identities, some Chaldean ultras and hardcore activists took the whole interview the wrong way, including Australian-based singer Yousif Aziz. Mr. Aziz - whom I respect a lot as an artist - who took the whole interview to mean that Danny Asmaro was promoting Assyrianism at the expense of the Chaldean identity and history of Alqosh. In an online post, in which he doesn't directly name Mr. Asmaro, he attacks the latter and goes on and on about how no effort by Danny Asmaro or Assyrian activities and parties can erase or take away from Alqosh's chaldean identity. For the record, the two singers have not only collaborated on a song and other musical projects in the past, I believe they are even related from distance. Out of anger for these attacks against him from Yousif Aziz, Danny Asmaro came out to only respond and defend himself, he even posted a picture of a winged bull, saying he will erect a statue of the Assyrian winged bull at the entrance of the site of Old Alqosh which he is personally working on. Of course, he didn't mean this literally, and it was a figurative attempt at those attacking him and questioning his loyalty to his Chaldean background, to benefit Assyrians instead.
Wuffff, I am tired just typing that!

As you can see, these three vicious attacks happened so close to each other, that you can't help but question if they are not coordinated, at least the two from the church clergy. Then sandwiched in-between was the attack from Yousif Aziz, whom I have followed for a while and although respect as a talented artist, he has shown an extreme anti-Assyrian rhetoric for years now, bordering line hate for anything Assyrian. Of course, this extreme behaviour exists on both sides, as we have our own sick Assyrians who despise the Chaldean name and so on. It is sad honestly, at a time when we should be all united, or at least not hating and attacking each other. But doesn't help when those at the top are spewing the hate, and even falsifying the bible, just to serve their Anti-Assyrian views and hate.

With full respect to the good Chaldean people out there, as I have personally seen how outraged a lot of them were, against the the attacks above.

Coming up in the next post, I will talk about the outpouring of outrage and condemnation against thee above, the like of which I have honestly never seen.Blue Beach Plain Collage Facebook Post.png
 
Last edited:
The Response

I have been online long enough - since 1997 to be exact - and I can confidently say I have never seen such a strong, outraged and unified response to these attack as what I have seen last few days. Honestly, nothing comes close. I mean the two events I remember that got us all united and up and in arms were in the Oct 2010 "Baghdad Church Massacre" and the 2014/2015 ISIS invasion of Iraq and Syria. Yes, no blood was spilled this time like we witnessed 10 and 15 years ago at the hands of terrorists, but it is painful and sad to see those who are supposed to guide and lead us, spreading hate and even taking liberty to interpret specific parts of the bible as they please, just to suite their anti-Assyrian rhetoric.

While Assyrian patriarch Mar Awa Rowel has yet to come out and publicly call out these comments by the Chaldean clergy, others in his clergy have, including Mar Melis and Mar Benjamin in Australia, Mar Odisho in Sweden and Mar Paules in Chicago and many others. The message from these and others had a similar point, that if you are going to claim these stories to be legends, then you are creating a slippery slope and allowing others to interpret things as they see fit. Not only that, it opens the door for others from non-Christian religious to claim our religious is built on false stories and legends. Another thing they argued is that if these Chaldean bishops think it is not scientifically or humanely possible for a man to be in the belly of a whale for three days and survive, then how are they to believe other stories in the bible that are even harder to believe from a scientific and logical prospective, including the raising of the dead, opening a sea and many other examples.

Most of the responses were a rebuttal to these claims that the Assyrian Empire was uniquely bloody and evil, by pointing out that violence was the universal language of power in the ancient world. Empires did not survive through diplomacy alone—especially not those under constant threat from rival kingdoms and invasions. To single out Assyria for brutality, as if its enemies were met with flowers and open arms elsewhere, is to judge the ancient world by modern moral standards while conveniently ignoring history.

Beyond warfare, the Assyrian Empire made enduring contributions to civilisation: advanced administration, legal systems, road networks, engineering, irrigation, medicine, and the preservation of knowledge through libraries such as Ashurbanipal’s-one of the earliest and most important libraries in human history. Assyria was not merely an empire of conquest, but one of organization, innovation, and cultural continuity. To reduce it to caricatures of violence is not only intellectually dishonest, but a deliberate erasure of a civilization that helped lay the foundations of the world we inherited.

Here are some response posts from Assyrian clergy or other activists. There are literally hundreds and I may post some more later.

Of course, some took the response too far and turned it into personal attacks, further deepening the divisions among our people. This is not only sad to see; it is proof that this rhetoric from these men of the Church is actually making things worse. We hope things settle down, and maybe, just maybe, for these bishops to come out and apologise or walk back their comments towards Assyrian history and empire. We want cooler heads to prevail and this heated anti-Assyrian discourse)
 
Back
Top