Argentina

gilbert

New member
Anyone watching the news? I dont get what's happening but there's some kind of protest and its getting ugly.

Anyone mind filling me in?
 
THE IDIOTS are protesting Bush's visit.

I wonder when did Bush invade their country? or when did the US attack them?

Oh yeah, it is protesting for the dsake of protesting.

ASHOOR
 
i would protest bush visiting my country too.. hell.. if i was an assassin.. i'd shoot down his damn helicopter.. and when it hit the ground.. i'd keep shooting :2guns: :ban:
 
How about if it then blew up in a fiery inferno. Would you keep shooting then.. Because I would be impressed if you did.. :biggrin:
 
ashoor said:
THE IDIOTS are protesting Bush's visit.

I wonder when did Bush invade their country? or when did the US attack them?

Oh yeah, it is protesting for the dsake of protesting.

ASHOOR

Ashoor they're not protesting for the sake of protesting. These are anti-globalization protesters. Heard of NAFTA? Well, there's talk brewing of a free trade act for all of the Americas. People are also there because they're still against the war in Iraq. It's the US policies that are bringing these people out.
 
You know what? The United States is fighting one cause, and that is to spread freedom. Thats what the war is truly about, thats what all this protesting is truly about. It is about people who want freedom and the convflicting ideals of those who dont. NAFTA is working beautifully, why wouldnt it work in the southern Americas? And Bush has one of the most efficient presidencies since Franklin Delano Roosevelt, anyone ever thought about that one?
 
david said:
And Bush has one of the most efficient presidencies since Franklin Delano Roosevelt, anyone ever thought about that one?

That depends on your definition of efficient......
 
well you tell me how he is not efficient, and i will explain to you why his presidency is :)

just a little bit of info: the American political system is EXTREMELY inefficient, simply because of the way The Founders structured the government. Think about what government really means, and then tell me we dont have a largely successful and efficient government.
 
you know whats funny? I have a feeling this is going to be one of those bashing threads... i can tell with the tone.

Anyways, efficiency in government DOES NOT require a list of accomplishments, for this would defeat the whole purpose of government (I will explain this below.) Do you know what Bush's primary focus was when he ran for the Presidency in 2000? Domestic policy. What happened one year later? 9/11. Bush was NOT a foreign policy expert like Nixon, he was not a legislative guru like Johnson, but his staff worked wonders and developed a doctrine on foreign policy that would forever change the face of the world.

First, let me start off by explaining what I mean by the efficiency of a presidency.

Our government, is set up around 3 doctrines: the Seperation of Powers, the Division of Powers, and Judicial Review (I won't speak to you as if I am teaching a government class, but I need to give a little background so that I can explain where I am coming from.) These three doctrines have helped maintain balance in our government and prevent any one branch to become too powerful, for Madison, Jefferson, Franklin all understood that a political system could quite easily become a monarchy if they did not approach this carefully.

Not only do the 3 doctrines balance each branch of government, but they are the engine for the inefficient government we have. Inefficient does not mean counter-productive! This is key to understanding political efficiency. Power is limited very effectively in our country, something the Founding Fathers were hoping for. It is incredibly hard to get anything done, pass bills, change laws, or manipulate the economy in such ways that government becomes too powerful. The fact that our government, in a sense, has power of recognition is what keeps citizens from trying to overthrow the government. But my main point is that limiting power in our government is what protects our rights as stated in the Constitution.

Henry Kissinger once said that "The American Political System is the only system in the world created solely for the advancement of mankind." The advancement of mankind, in this instance, and also what is the basis of our government, was the protection and advancement of human freedom. You may ask what the basis of freedom is, or what is regarded as freedom? Well lets take a look at our Constitution. John Locke, in his Two Treatsies of Government said "men are endowed by their creator certain inalienable rights", and the Founders said that among those rights were life, liberty, and happiness (Locke specified property for this third right.)

The creation of government was to enhance human freedom, not to take away from what freedom we already have. Here is where Constitutionalism comes into play. What is the true purpose to our Constitution? Simply put, our Constitution's purpose is to advance the rule of law to tell the majority what it can't do. The majority does not need Constitutional protection, they are the majority. They can decide anything they want to do. Government is created, and ours based on the Constitution, to ensure the freedoms of man and to tell the majority what it cannot do.

Now, how does this all have to do with President Bush and his political efficiency? Well, I am glad you asked :)

The Bush Doctrine has pushed for the freedom of people throughout the world, as long as they want it. People naturally want freedom, no one wants to feel oppressed and choaked off from public view. Through foreign policy, Bush's presidency is carrying on what the purpose of government is truly about: to protect the freedoms of mankind, freedom from oppression and inequality. There are 190 countries in the world, roughly 6 billion people populating the globe, and did you know that less than 50% of the world's population is considered free? President Clinton once said that "half free is the most freedom we have ever had in the world", but how unfortunate? The Bush camp has been pushing to change that.

With the onslaught of dictatorship regimes in the Middle East and the uprising of anarchists around the globe, human freedom cannot possibly be accomplished without someone there to guide the world. The problem with Americans today is that we always complain that the government isnt doing enough for us, that the government is not allowing us enough freedom. But does anyone remember what President Kennedy said? "Ask not what your country can do for you, but ask what you can do for your country." What can American's do? They can support their political advisors, who are doing an outstanding job with the global freedom campain. So what if the government isnt giving us tax breaks, so what if the government is trying to reform Social Security? That is most definately the most important issue here. Those are all nickel and dime issues. The most important issue, the basis for government, is to ensure the inalienable rights of human beings.

Our government, interestingly enough, is quite efficient in one instance: wartime. We can move swiftly and accurately, and Congress is left catching up. By all means the Presidency today is efficient. We are hitting all the important aspects of government: limiting power (in this case, limiting the foreign power of military regimes), protecting human liberties, and advancing the freedom of man. So you tell me, is the Presidency still inefficient?

Or maybe your definition of political efficiency is different than mine? But if you want a "hard" list of accomplishments, I guess I can scrape up some information. I am sure there is plenty his staff has done besides the most IMPORTANT accomplishment of implementing some of the world's greatest foreign policy.
 
Oh but gilbert, Argentinian's are protesting against the FTAA that Bush is there to promote. Some say it would rival the European Union in size, but what I fail to understand is why people are against it? Do the Argentinians themselves not know that close to 40% of their population remain in poverty, that jobs will open with this proposed free trade agreement? I guess not... it is quite unfortunate, that some countries still think they have to prove themselves to be self sufficient to be acknowledged by the global economy... :bangin:
 
David, i hope you didnt just type all that up, because I was just aiming for a quick "har" by poking fun at bush. :biggrin:
 
L33tKevin said:
David, i hope you didnt just type all that up, because I was just aiming for a quick "har" by poking fun at bush. :biggrin:

lol, yup. I just finished typing it. Thats why it took so long to reply :mrgreen: I dont mind poking at Bush, go ahead do it all you want :)
 
Brazil, Argentina and the rest of South America has suffered the most from Bush and his winner take all policies. Their economies are close to bankrupcy (how quickly eveyone forgets the protests in Argentina about 3 years ago when a civil war almos broke out). Bush interferes in Venezuela's politics (surprise surprise, they have huge oil reserves). Bush is against Brazil's President Lula (surprise surprise, a man who gets along wth Fidel Castro).

When the USA stops meddling in other people's affairs and ruining other country's economies (its ok if they help the countries but till now, name one country that the USA has helped), that will be the day when their presiden will be welcome into their country.

Vamos Vamos Argentina
VIVA Brazil
Chi Chi Le Le Le VIVA Chile!!!

(I will not brng Uruguay into it because of what is happening in the Centenario Stadium next week)
 
Moja Moja said:
Brazil, Argentina and the rest of South America has suffered the most from Bush and his winner take all policies. Their economies are close to bankrupcy (how quickly eveyone forgets the protests in Argentina about 3 years ago when a civil war almos broke out). Bush interferes in Venezuela's politics (surprise surprise, they have huge oil reserves). Bush is against Brazil's President Lula (surprise surprise, a man who gets along wth Fidel Castro).

When the USA stops meddling in other people's affairs and ruining other country's economies (its ok if they help the countries but till now, name one country that the USA has helped), that will be the day when their presiden will be welcome into their country.

Vamos Vamos Argentina
VIVA Brazil
Chi Chi Le Le Le VIVA Chile!!!

(I will not brng Uruguay into it because of what is happening in the Centenario Stadium next week)

lol... i like how everyone refers back to the oil issue. here is like, the best, most sarcastic answer you will ever get from me.

if we REALLY, REALLY wanted oil, we could just invade Mexico in like.... 3 days and have all the oil we want. Do you realize that it wouldn't even be that hard? we could all just drive down there and say "give us your oil, and they would hand it over". Seriously its not about oil.

And if it IS about oil, and if we are in the Middle East for oil, go ahead and answer me this: do you even know just how much oil we actually get from the middle east? Do you even know where we get oil? If you can answer those then I guess I have a reason to debate with you, but until then, I will just sit back, eat some popcorn, and watch the sparks fly as this turns into a Bush bashing thread :bangin:
 
You know what? The United States is fighting one cause, and that is to spread freedom. Thats what the war is truly about, thats what all this protesting is truly about. It is about people who want freedom and the convflicting ideals of those who dont. NAFTA is working beautifully, why wouldnt it work in the southern Americas? And Bush has one of the most efficient presidencies since Franklin Delano Roosevelt, anyone ever thought about that one?

typical republican response...fighting one cause...spread freedom...most efficent presidencies better? In terms of economy, or hatred around the world. Economy is terrible, job loss is horrible, gas prices, we're out of the World Court, those are the first few things that come to mind. We're bogged down in two countries with our sights already on another. What kind of crack you smoking man, i want some. Psharafookh you call that effective, i study political science, so dont give me those never ending terms quotes summaries, its a failure nasha.
 
Aside from protesting against the attempted expansion of the free trade area, there is also a domestic side issue concentrating on a lack of jobs....

The theory behind expanding the free trade area IS a win/win situation for South America as that would open up their market for any goods produced to be exported to America at a lower cost due to the removal of tariffs that comes with operating within a free trade area...

I'm no expert on NAFTA, being from UK, I'm more familiar with the EU and with the recent accession of 10 eastern European states, many of which were formerly under communist rule, they have done nothing but prosper so far, with many witnessing growth levels that is competing with the likes of UK, France, Germany et al...
 
petervocals said:
You know what? The United States is fighting one cause, and that is to spread freedom. Thats what the war is truly about, thats what all this protesting is truly about. It is about people who want freedom and the convflicting ideals of those who dont. NAFTA is working beautifully, why wouldnt it work in the southern Americas? And Bush has one of the most efficient presidencies since Franklin Delano Roosevelt, anyone ever thought about that one?

typical republican response...fighting one cause...spread freedom...most efficent presidencies better? In terms of economy, or hatred around the world. Economy is terrible, job loss is horrible, gas prices, we're out of the World Court, those are the first few things that come to mind. We're bogged down in two countries with our sights already on another. What kind of crack you smoking man, i want some. Psharafookh you call that effective, i study political science, so dont give me those never ending terms quotes summaries, its a failure nasha.

when did i say anything about our economy? job loss is horrible? last time i checked (which was this morning) our unemployment rate was 5.22%, gas prices have decreased by at least 40 cents nationwide, and do you even realize how much OTHER countries pay for gas? we are still considered cheap. just because Americans are complaining about 2.5 dollars in their gas guzzling SUVs doesnt mean it is the President's fault. And due to recent NATIONAL DISASTERS, you cant but help watch the gas prices go up and down. Let me guess, you think it's Bush's fault the gas prices shot up after both Hurricanes? I study Political Science as well man, what makes what you study any better than what I study?

*CNN Money Reports that at least 5 other countries right now have gas prices of $5.00 or more per gallon.click here

*The Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco projected that inflation will continue to significantly decrease due to falling energy prices. The natural disasters have created a major economic contraction for the quarter in the Gulf Region, which naturally will push inflation up in that area coupled with an increase in unemployment. THIS IS WHAT WE ARE TRYING TO GET OVER RIGHT NOW. GDP has been moving on a steady 3.3% increase from the second quarter only to be slightly stunted in the third quarter as a result from the natural disasters in the Gulf Region. The rebuilding effort that has begun in the Gulf Region will dramatically push GDP beyond potential due to the increase in government expenditure. There had been a 17,000 job loss in September, but that was held up by the 252,000 increase to the labor force. click here

Oh, and the point of being bogged down in two countries: How many troops do we actually have in both Iraq and Afghanistan? Maybe you underestimate the power of the American Army.

*We have 150,000 soldiers dispersed throughout the Middle East. Of course, many of them are involved with the occupation of Iraq until the Iraqi Armed Forces build up sufficient numbers to be able to maintain control. Iraqi President Talabani projected that 50,000 soldiers will be discharged from service in Iraq this year and be replaced by Iraqi soldiers. click here

*Less than 7,800 soldiers remain in Afghanistan. We have over 1.4 million people in uniform, and roughly 350,000 of them are overseas. We have plenty of military power, and we are not even using a ludicrous amount ot back the campaign in Iraq or Afghanistan. The strikes on both Iraq and Afghanistan were 17 days and 21 days long, respectively. I know that speaking about casualties is a touchy subject for most, but we have only lost a little over 2000 soldiers in Iraqclick here and Afghanistan was hardly as "devestating".

So why again, is Bush inefficient? Politics does not ONLY deal with domestic issues, and you should know that if you study Political Science. Global Politics is what we are dealing with today, we most certainly dont want to go back into our hiding hole like we did before World War II. Being a country with great political power and great military force, we should, by all means, help people who want it.

And what makes you think I am Republican? Dont ostracize me yet from liberal views simply because of my take on foreign diplomacy. I'd like to consider myself a Liberal Socialist as well as a George Bush (senior) conservative, which interestingly, smacks me right in the middle of the linear model of politics: conservative democrat! Isnt that grand? :giggle:

MACHIAVELLI said:
Aside from protesting against the attempted expansion of the free trade area, there is also a domestic side issue concentrating on a lack of jobs....

The theory behind expanding the free trade area IS a win/win situation for South America as that would open up their market for any goods produced to be exported to America at a lower cost due to the removal of tariffs that comes with operating within a free trade area...

I'm no expert on NAFTA, being from UK, I'm more familiar with the EU and with the recent accession of 10 eastern European states, many of which were formerly under communist rule, they have done nothing but prosper so far, with many witnessing growth levels that is competing with the likes of UK, France, Germany et al...

Exactly! The domestic issue for the people of Argentina is that they are unsure of what the FTAA will bring to them. They are in dire straights for unemployment. There are over 36 million Argentinians, and about 40% are unemployed. They NEED SOME RESOLUTION! And I was just about to say how well countries that join the EU seem to be doing, thank you for coming in as a breathe of fresh air!
 
I don't hear the Brazilians complaining. They use ethanol-based propulsion for their vehicles and sell gasoline as well. I guess for a South American country, they're doing pretty bad haha. As far as bashing Bush, give it a break. We've heard it before. Moderates all the way.

I give David props. Peter bro, you're a smart guy, but most politics is taught by biased professors with a liberal agenda. It is known as pure fact and the stuff their teaching you is part of that agenda. I'm not some conservative monkey, but I just think both sides are pathetic and they shouldn't blame an ex pot-smoking hick from Texas with a rich background. Look at the nation as whole and the facts david pulled out aren't from his ishta, their true. Right after Clinton left, things went to hell. Ask yourselves what would have happened if 9/11 didn't occur, where the state of our nation would be?
 
RadRides said:
I don't hear the Brazilians complaining. They use ethanol-based propulsion for their vehicles and sell gasoline as well. I guess for a South American country, they're doing pretty bad haha. As far as bashing Bush, give it a break. We've heard it before. Moderates all the way.

I give David props. Peter bro, you're a smart guy, but most politics is taught by biased professors with a liberal agenda. It is known as pure fact and the stuff their teaching you is part of that agenda. I'm not some conservative monkey, but I just think both sides are pathetic and they shouldn't blame an ex pot-smoking hick from Texas with a rich background. Look at the nation as whole and the facts david pulled out aren't from his ishta, their true. Right after Clinton left, things went to hell. Ask yourselves what would have happened if 9/11 didn't occur, where the state of our nation would be?

thanks aot Rad Rides, I appreciate it. I am not here to put down anyone, just here to provide the facts of my opinion. I respect everyone's opinion, but what I find more important is the factual evidence you can provide. Without it, words mean nothing and the term "crazy liberal" comes to mind, lol. Anyways, nice having a good political convo with you guys.
 
Back
Top